The names of the colors are too small to read. Please tell us which is which in a comment.

To the left of the door: BM Apollo Blue on the left, SW Foggy Days on the right
To the right of door under the light: BM Apollo on top, SW Foggy Days on bottom
On the door: SW Ryegrass on top, SW Tansy Green on bottom

I like the BM Apollo best. Dark but not too dark. It’s a cute house! It’s going to look great!

I like Apollo, too. I also like the colors BM recommends to pair with it. Greenhow Blue would look so good on your front door. Use either White Dove or Edgecomb Gray for trim.

Thank you so much for the ideas. Three houses around us all have light blue doors, so was trying something different. Not sold on the green once it was painted on the door. Eventually we would like to replace door - add it to that list!

I like White Dove - used it in 2 rooms inside. Currently SW Greek Villa is selected for the trim. Painter is using SW, so was trying to stick with their colors even though Ive been told they can color match.

I’m open to other blue-gray suggestions, but don’t want to go darker than these two. It seems Apollo is currently the better choice, my husband just doesn’t see it as “blue”.

I'd be tempted to test some where I could see the paint against the roof as well

I really like the Apollo Blue based on your photos. I do see a green undertone in houssaon’s example, but that wouldn’t be a bad thing for me.

I can definitely see the green in Apollo Blue. I like it and based on your photos it’s a good fit with the brick. That being said, the Foggy Day is also nice, especially if your husband wants blue. Do you see any purple-ish undertone in FD? I think I see a little in your first pic of the evening photos above. Hard to tell for sure online.

I saw purple undertones, too. Someone suggested it was because the original yellowish paint is showing through. I thought I preferred Apollo until I saw it in the bright light. This morning, I picked up a sample of Cadet and Uncertain Gray, both on the same strip as Foggy Day. On a whim, I saw the Suburban Modern brochure at SW, so I grabbed a sample of Breezy. I definitely spiraled this weekend, but have to make a decision today.

Trust me, I know deciding can be hard. We had our exterior painted not long ago. I had 9 sample cans of colors and some Samplize swatches. It paid off in the end!

BM Apollo Blue looks prettier for me.

I vote Apollo Blue BM

Be brave! Testing, re-thinking, painting sections and searching for another color is not going to make you suddenly say "ahhh that's it!"

When the house is completely painted you will say AHHH It looks great, why didn't we do this sooner. Trust yourself, your instinct is on target with the Apollo Blue it is going to be Striking. Can't wait to see it, when it is done.